Gravity Requirements
Purpose
This document defines what a physical mechanism for gravity must accomplish.
It does not specify what gravity is, what produces it, what carries it, or how its mechanism must be implemented.
Existing gravitational observations establish required behavior. Candidate mechanisms must reproduce that behavior without having the desired result inserted into them as an unexplained primitive.
The Scope of Gravitatis
The immediate objective is to identify and experimentally test a physical mechanism for gravity. We examine the behavior, distribution, propagation, and interaction of energy, including energy associated with particles and matter.
The working hypothesis is that gravity may respond to electromagnetic energy regardless of its organization: coherent radiation, incoherent noise, reflected energy, reactive fields, or energy bound within particles and matter. Whether these contributions produce the same gravitational response is a question to test, not a conclusion.
The origin of energy, charge, and particles is not a prerequisite for investigating gravity.
We do not require energy to create particles, particles to create energy, or either to precede the other. Their observable properties are sufficient starting conditions for this investigation. Questions about particle structure and origins deserve their own investigations; they need not be settled first.
From Outputs to Mechanisms
We begin with the machine already operating. A trajectory, clock reading, phase shift, wavelength, delay, detector response, or acceleration is a test point. It does not automatically reveal the circuitry behind it.
OBSERVED OUTPUT
↑
CANDIDATE PHYSICAL MECHANISM
↑
MEASURABLE CONDITIONS
Candidate functions include establishing gradients, coupling, propagation, reflection, phase response, delay, storage and release, feedback, thresholds, resonance, redistribution, and acceleration. We ask what a mechanism must do before naming what it is.
One Candidate: Energy and Propagation
One possibility is that an energy distribution alters the local electromagnetic response encountered by other disturbances. If that response varies with position, passing energy may experience changes in propagation, phase, delay, or direction.
ENERGY DISTRIBUTION
↓
LOCAL RESPONSE / REACTANCE
↓
PROPAGATION CHANGE
↓
OBSERVABLE MOTION
In a simple electromagnetic medium, useful reference relationships are:
These are clues, not evidence by themselves that field energy changes vacuum permittivity or permeability. The missing connection is whether an energy distribution can establish a measurable propagation-response gradient without a material conductor.
A Gravity Relationship Under Investigation
One candidate model associates acceleration with the spatial gradient of a local propagation-speed field, \(c(\mathbf{x})\):
The expression has the dimensions of acceleration. It is a proposed kinematic relationship, not a demonstration that such a speed field exists or that it produces gravity. The physical origin and measurable consequences of that field remain on the test bench.
For an approximately spherical source, a basic external behavior to reproduce is \(g(r)\propto 1/r^2\). Matching that behavior is a test; it is not an explanation of its cause.
Rules of the Bench
- Distinguish measured behavior from its interpretation.
- Identify the input, physical response, and output of each mechanism.
- Use equations to support mechanisms, not replace them.
- Keep coherent, incoherent, propagating, and stored energy distinct.
- Make predictions that can fail; do not repair a model silently.
- Do not install as a premise what the investigation is meant to explain.
- Do not require earlier PRINCIPIA ideas to survive an audit.
Established theory, experimental records, and practical engineering provide evidence about how nature behaves. They are available for inspection, but none is compulsory circuitry for a clean-sheet model.
Existing physics is tracing paper.
Nature remains the circuit board.
System Boundary
The initial system contains two distinguishable participants, provisionally designated UNIT A and UNIT B.
No assumption is initially made concerning their composition, internal structure, mass, charge, energy content, or the property responsible for gravitational interaction.
The design must determine which characteristics, if any, must be assigned to the Units in order to reproduce observed gravitational behavior.
Functional Requirements
Establish a Relationship
The system shall permit UNIT A and UNIT B to have distinguishable physical locations or states such that their relationship can affect the resulting gravitational behavior.
Depend Upon Separation
The gravitational response shall vary when the separation between participating Units is changed.
Produce Directional Behavior
The mechanism shall account for the observed direction of gravitational acceleration between participating Units.
Reproduce the Inverse-Square Limit
For an appropriate isolated, approximately spherical source condition, the mechanism shall reproduce the observed inverse-square dependence:
This relationship is a required transfer characteristic and shall not itself be treated as the physical mechanism.
Account for Source Dependence
The mechanism shall identify the physical characteristic or characteristics of a Unit that determine the magnitude of the gravitational response associated with it.
Those characteristics shall be derived, identified, or independently justified rather than introduced solely because they reproduce the desired gravitational result.
Account for Response Dependence
The mechanism shall identify what characteristic of a responding Unit permits it to undergo gravitational acceleration.
The design shall account for the observed near-independence of free-fall acceleration from the composition of the responding body under equivalent conditions.
Support Multiple Units
The mechanism shall extend beyond an isolated two-Unit case and account for the combined gravitational behavior of multiple participating Units.
The manner in which multiple contributions combine shall be explicitly defined and testable.
Account for Orbital Behavior
The mechanism shall reproduce stable and changing orbital behavior within the accuracy required by observation.
Orbital motion shall emerge from the same gravitational mechanism used for the simpler two-Unit case rather than requiring an unrelated gravitational process.
Account for the Behavior of Propagating Signals
The mechanism shall account for established gravitational effects upon electromagnetic propagation, including observed changes in path and propagation timing.
The design shall distinguish the measured signal behavior from the interpretation assigned to that behavior.
Account for Clock Comparisons
The mechanism shall reproduce established differences observed when clocks operating under different gravitational conditions are compared.
The requirement specifies the observed comparison. It does not prescribe whether the underlying cause is time, propagation, clock operation, environmental interaction, or another mechanism.
Account for Dynamic Gravity
The mechanism shall account for observations demonstrating that gravitational relationships can change and that gravitational disturbances can propagate.
Any propagation speed, latency, or transmission mechanism required by the design must be explicitly identified rather than assumed.
Establish Physical Causality
The mechanism shall provide an identifiable physical relationship between an initiating event and its resulting response.
For an event at UNIT A to influence UNIT B, the design shall identify the interaction, coupling, or transmission process responsible.
The mechanism shall account for continuity of interaction, propagation latency where applicable, and the conditions necessary for a measurable response.
Temporal correlation alone shall not be accepted as proof of a causal connection. A common influence or shared reference must be considered and distinguished.
Any proposed transmission medium, field, impedance, admittance, threshold, or other implementation shall be justified by the candidate mechanism rather than installed as a prerequisite.
Conserve Physical Bookkeeping
Any state change, acceleration, transfer, storage, release, or redistribution required by the proposed mechanism shall have identifiable physical bookkeeping.
The design shall not rely upon undeclared sources, sinks, forces, references, clocks, or information paths.
Design Constraints
No Gravity Primitive
Gravity, gravitational force, gravitational attraction, gravitational potential, or equivalent terminology shall not be installed as an unexplained component whose behavior already contains the result being sought.
No Prescribed Medium
The requirements do not assume the existence or absence of a material medium, substrate, field, geometric structure, particle, or other implementation.
No Prescribed Propagation Model
The requirements do not assume that the local propagation speed of electromagnetic energy is constant or variable.
Either behavior must be established independently if it becomes necessary to the mechanism.
No Prescribed Time Model
The requirements do not prescribe whether time itself changes, remains invariant, or is merely represented through physical clocks and propagation processes.
Existing Theory Is Not the Mechanism
Newtonian gravitation, General Relativity, and other successful descriptions may provide observations, transfer characteristics, mathematical relationships, limiting cases, and acceptance tests.
Their physical interpretations are not automatically installed as components of the new design.
Minimum Necessary Complexity
Candidate designs should use the minimum number of independent functions and assumptions necessary to reproduce the required behavior.
Additional complexity must be justified by a requirement that cannot otherwise be satisfied.
Verification Requirements
Identifiable Interfaces
Every functional block shall have identifiable inputs, outputs, references, state, and control signals where applicable.
Accessible Test Points
Connections between functional blocks shall be treated as conceptual test points wherever possible.
Expected values, relationships, waveforms, directions, rates, phases, states, or limits shall be recorded when they become known.
Theory of Operation
Every functional block included in the gravity design shall have a stated purpose explaining what it does and why it is required.
Behavioral Verification
Candidate block diagrams and schematics shall be tested analytically, numerically, or experimentally as appropriate to determine whether their intermediate and final outputs satisfy the requirements.
Failure Must Remain Visible
A failed requirement shall not be repaired by silently changing a component, assumption, parameter, or interpretation.
The failure shall identify the block, interface, assumption, or architecture requiring reconsideration.
Discriminating Test
A completed candidate mechanism shall identify at least one observation or experiment capable of distinguishing its physical operation from a competing mechanism wherever such a distinction is experimentally accessible.
Out of Scope
This gravity design is not presently required to explain:
- the origin of the universe,
- the origin of energy,
- the physical construction of photons,
- the origin of charge,
- the emergence of quantum mechanics,
- the construction of matter or particles,
- cosmological redshift,
- dark matter or dark energy,
- the formation of galaxies,
- or the unification of all physical interactions.
If the gravity mechanism later produces consequences relevant to any of these subjects, they may be investigated separately. They are not requirements of the present design.
Acceptance
A candidate gravity mechanism is not accepted merely because its final equation reproduces a known gravitational result.
Its functional blocks, interfaces, intermediate behavior, physical bookkeeping, and limiting behavior must form a coherent causal path from the declared inputs to the observed output.