Silicon Bonding Energy and Gravitational Response
Abstract
Amorphous and crystalline silicon can contain the same number of silicon atoms while storing different amounts of internal energy. Heating amorphous silicon can permit its atoms to crystallize without melting; the rearrangement releases measurable heat. This study audits the complete energy accounting and asks whether the change in a sample's gravitational response has been measured independently of the calorimetric energy change. A prediction derived from mass–energy equivalence is not itself a measurement of gravitational weight.
The Physical Comparison
Consider a closed sample of pure silicon in two states: amorphous before crystallization, crystalline afterward. Keep the number and isotopic composition of atoms fixed. Compare both final states at the same temperature, pressure, and measurement environment. This comparison isolates the change in bonding and structural energy from the energy temporarily supplied to heat the material. Solid-phase crystallization produces polycrystalline material in many procedures; a perfect single crystal is not required for the comparison.
The distinction is not that the crystalline specimen contains fewer atoms. It is that its lower-energy arrangement has released some stored structural energy to its surroundings.
What Has Actually Been Measured?
Kail and collaborators (2011) measured crystallization enthalpy in vapor-deposited amorphous silicon using differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). Values for their investigated materials ranged approximately from 200 to 480 J/g, with a minimum near 240 ± 25 J/g for relaxed amorphous silicon. Sample preparation, hydrogen content, and structural defects matter; these values are not a universal correction applicable to any silicon sample.
The calorimeter measures heat flow associated with the structural transformation. It does not weigh the gravitational mass difference. Nor is the measured crystallization enthalpy the total electric energy expended by the furnace.
Conservation Across the Entire Process
We must draw an explicit system boundary. During annealing, a heater supplies energy, the sample warms and rearranges, and energy leaves into the calorimeter, furnace, and room. The sample's final energy is compared only after it returns to the original reference temperature.
For the complete closed apparatus, energy entering or leaving through wires, radiation, mechanical work, or other paths must also be counted. The furnace does not create an unexplained sample mass deficit: it helps the solid overcome a rearrangement barrier, and the lower-energy crystalline state releases previously stored energy. That stored excess originated when the amorphous state was produced. With a sufficiently careful thermodynamic correction, the structural energy difference can be separated from ordinary heating and cooling.
The published DSC quantity is an enthalpy difference. For solids at nearly constant pressure, the corresponding internal-energy difference differs by a pressure–volume term; that correction must be evaluated in a precision experiment rather than silently ignored.
Predicted Mass Equivalent
For a worked example, take 1.000 kg of relaxed amorphous silicon with a structural energy excess of 240 J/g. If that energy leaves the sample during crystallization, the sample ends with 240,000 J less energy at the same temperature.
Using the conventional mass–energy relation as a test prediction, not as a measured gravitational result:
This is about 2.67 nanograms per kilogram of silicon, or a fractional change of approximately 2.67 parts in a trillion. The quoted value uses the SI reference speed \(c_0=299\,792\,458\ \mathrm{m/s}\) to state the established benchmark prediction. In PRINCIPIA GRAVITATIS, any proposed alternative rule must make a separate quantitative prediction; substituting a variable propagation speed into this formula without deriving the energy accounting is not sufficient.
What Would the Gravitational Measurement Show?
If passive gravitational mass tracks the lost internal energy exactly, the expected change in Earth's gravitational force on the one-kilogram specimen is:
This force is only about 26 piconewtons. It is a predicted difference between two equilibrated states, not the force generated by the heating pulse. Thermal convection, buoyancy, gas adsorption, surface contamination, mechanical strain, magnetic forces, static charge, vibration, and sample transfer can all masquerade as much larger changes.
Three measurements must be kept distinct: (a) the heat released by structural rearrangement, (b) any resulting change in inertial mass, and (c) any resulting change in gravitational response. Agreement of (a) with a theoretical estimate of (b) does not directly measure (c).
Proposed Differential Experiment
Use high-purity, compositionally characterized silicon. Determine the structural-energy difference calorimetrically on representative specimens. Where practical, use matched amorphous and crystalline reference samples and a reversible measurement arrangement; crystallization itself is not readily reversible without recreating the amorphous state.
- Before: measure the specimen's gravitational force or acceleration relative to a controlled reference, at a fixed reference temperature and environment.
- Transformation: crystallize the silicon by controlled solid-phase annealing; log the supplied electrical energy, calorimeter heat flow, elapsed time, and any lost or added material.
- After: restore the same reference conditions, confirm the structural change and composition, and repeat the gravitational measurement.
- Controls: run an already-crystalline specimen through the same heating cycle; repeat with changed orientations, blind sequencing, and independently calibrated forces.
The heating cycle must not be confused with the comparison itself. Heating temporarily adds internal energy; the desired comparison is between two cooled specimens with identical atomic inventory but different stored bonding energy.
The Audit Criterion
The conventional benchmark predicts that gravitational mass changes in proportion to total internal energy, independent of whether that energy is expressed as atomic disorder, chemical bonding, heat, or radiation. The proposed gravity mechanism can agree or disagree, but it must identify the observable and predict a difference large enough to test.
For this narrowly defined test, \(\eta_E=1\) represents the conventional expectation. A verified value different from unity would demand investigation, including an audit of systematic errors. This ratio describes a change in passive gravitational mass; determining the sample's gravitational influence on a separate body is a distinct, still more difficult measurement of active gravitational mass.
Related Evidence — Not the Same Experiment
A 2005 study by Rainville and collaborators compared precise atomic mass differences with nuclear gamma-ray energy in silicon and sulfur isotopes, confirming mass–energy equivalence to high precision. That is compelling evidence regarding nuclear binding energy, but it is not a direct weighing of the gravitational mass change when bulk amorphous silicon crystallizes. Equivalence-principle experiments with differing materials and atomic internal states provide other indirect constraints; they should not be presented as the requested bulk-silicon measurement.
Status and Conclusion
Measured: an enthalpy difference exists between amorphous and crystalline silicon; crystallization releases measurable heat.
Predicted: if an isolated sample loses that energy, its mass equivalent decreases by approximately 2.67 ng per kilogram for a 240 J/g change; the corresponding difference in Earth-weight is approximately 26 pN.
Not established by the cited silicon calorimetry: a direct, independent observation of that predicted change in gravitational force or of a change in the field produced by the sample.
Open question for PRINCIPIA GRAVITATIS: Does gravitational response quantitatively track structural energy retained in otherwise identical matter? This study specifies the accounting and the required measurement rather than presuming the result.
Sources and Further Reading
- F. Kail et al., “The configurational energy gap between amorphous and crystalline silicon,” physica status solidi RRL (2011). DOI: 10.1002/pssr.201105333.
- S. Rainville et al., “World Year of Physics: a direct test of E=mc²,” Nature 438, 1096–1097 (2005). DOI: 10.1038/4381096a.
- “Joint mass-and-energy test of the equivalence principle at the 10⁻¹⁰ level using atoms with specified mass and internal energy,” Physical Review A 104 (2021). DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevA.104.022822.