EXPERIMENT: Bartlett–Corle Measurement of Maxwell's Displacement Current

Abstract

In 1985, D. F. Bartlett and T. R. Corle of the University of Colorado reported a direct measurement of the magnetic field inside a thin, circular parallel-plate capacitor while the capacitor was being charged. The experiment was designed to test the magnetic field associated with Maxwell's displacement-current term.

The importance of the experiment lies in the region in which the measurement was made. Between the capacitor plates there is no ordinary conduction current crossing the dielectric gap. Nevertheless, while the electric field between the plates changes with time, Maxwell's equations predict a magnetic field surrounding the changing electric flux.

Bartlett and Corle measured this magnetic field directly. They reported that its magnitude varied linearly with radial distance from the capacitor axis, as predicted for a uniform displacement current. The measured slope of magnetic field versus radius agreed with the theoretical prediction to within approximately five percent.

Historical Background

Ampère's original circuital law related magnetic circulation to conduction current:

\[ \oint_C \mathbf{B}\cdot d\mathbf{l} = \mu_0 I_{\mathrm{cond}}. \]

A charging capacitor presents an apparent difficulty. Conduction current exists in the wires leading to the capacitor plates, but no corresponding stream of conduction electrons crosses the insulating space between the plates.

Maxwell resolved this discontinuity by adding the time-changing electric-flux term:

\[ \oint_C \mathbf{B}\cdot d\mathbf{l} = \mu_0 \left( I_{\mathrm{cond}} + \epsilon_0\frac{d\Phi_E}{dt} \right). \]

The additional quantity

\[ I_D = \epsilon_0\frac{d\Phi_E}{dt} \]

is conventionally called the displacement current.

In differential form, the Ampère–Maxwell equation is:

\[ \boxed{ \nabla\times\mathbf{B} = \mu_0\mathbf{J} + \mu_0\epsilon_0 \frac{\partial\mathbf{E}}{\partial t} } \]

The first term represents conduction-current density. The second represents the contribution of a changing electric field.

The Important Distinction

Displacement current does not mean that conduction charge crosses the capacitor gap.

When a capacitor is charged, electrons are transported through the external conductors and accumulate on the capacitor plates. In the dielectric region between the plates, however, there need not be a corresponding conduction current.

What changes between the plates is the electric field:

\[ \frac{\partial\mathbf{E}}{\partial t}\neq0. \]

Maxwell's equation assigns this changing electric field the same role in producing magnetic circulation that conduction current occupies in the original Ampère law.

The Bartlett–Corle Experiment

Bartlett and Corle constructed a thin circular parallel-plate capacitor and measured the magnetic field directly inside the capacitor while it was being charged.

For an ideal circular capacitor with a spatially uniform changing electric field, consider an Amperian circular path of radius \(r\) centered on the capacitor axis.

The electric flux enclosed by that path is:

\[ \Phi_E(r) = E\pi r^2. \]

The corresponding displacement current enclosed by the path is:

\[ I_D(r) = \epsilon_0 \frac{d\Phi_E}{dt} = \epsilon_0\pi r^2 \frac{dE}{dt}. \]

Applying the Ampère–Maxwell law:

\[ B(r)(2\pi r) = \mu_0 I_D(r). \]

Substitution gives:

\[ B(r)(2\pi r) = \mu_0\epsilon_0\pi r^2 \frac{dE}{dt}. \]

Therefore:

\[ \boxed{ B(r) = \frac{\mu_0\epsilon_0}{2} r\frac{dE}{dt} } \]

and consequently:

\[ \boxed{B(r)\propto r}. \]

The magnetic field inside the idealized capacitor should therefore increase linearly with radial distance from its central axis.

Experimental Result

Bartlett and Corle reported precisely this linear radial dependence. Their measured magnetic field varied linearly with distance from the capacitor axis, consistent with the prediction for a uniform displacement current.

The measured slope

\[ \frac{dB}{dr} \]

agreed with the predicted value to within approximately 5 percent.

A measurable magnetic field existed in a region where no ordinary conduction current crossed the capacitor gap.

What the Experiment Established

The experiment provides direct experimental support for the magnetic field predicted by the displacement-current term of the Ampère–Maxwell equation.

It is important, however, to state the result precisely.

The experiment did not demonstrate that electrons flowed from one capacitor plate to the other. Instead, it measured the magnetic field associated with the time-varying electric field in the region between the plates.

Thus the experimentally demonstrated sequence is:

\[ \boxed{ \text{changing charge separation} \rightarrow \frac{\partial\mathbf{E}}{\partial t} \rightarrow \mathbf{B} } \]

without requiring:

\[ \boxed{ \text{conduction-charge transport across the gap}. } \]

Why This Experiment Is Mechanistically Interesting

The Bartlett–Corle experiment separates two mechanisms that can appear together in an ordinary wire.

In the conductor:

\[ \mathbf{J}_{\mathrm{cond}}\neq0. \]

In the ideal capacitor gap:

\[ \mathbf{J}_{\mathrm{cond}}=0, \]

while:

\[ \frac{\partial\mathbf{E}}{\partial t}\neq0. \]

Nevertheless, a magnetic field is observed.

This makes the capacitor gap an unusually useful experimental region for asking what is physically occurring when electromagnetic influence is transferred through a region without corresponding conduction-charge transport.

Relevance to the PRINCIPIA HISTORICA Investigation

The experimental result itself belongs to established electromagnetism. PRINCIPIA HISTORICA does not need to reinterpret or dispute the measured magnetic field.

Instead, the experiment raises a deeper mechanistic question relevant to the substrate investigation:

If conduction charge does not cross the capacitor gap, what physical electromagnetic state occupies that region and communicates the changing charge condition from one part of the field to another?

Standard electrodynamics describes that state through the electric and magnetic fields themselves. PRINCIPIA HISTORICA investigates whether those fields should additionally be understood as the physical energetic state from which the effective propagation substrate emerges.

The distinction is subtle but important. The Bartlett–Corle experiment does not establish the PRINCIPIA HISTORICA substrate hypothesis. Rather, it provides an experimentally accessible example in which:

\[ \boxed{ \text{field change} \rightarrow \text{field response} } \]

occurs across a region without conduction-current transport.

The Question Left Open

The experiment establishes a measurable magnetic response associated with a changing electric field in the capacitor gap. It does not, by itself, identify a mechanical carrier for that response or determine whether a substrate distinct from the fields is required.

This distinction defines the next investigative task: separate what is measured from the mechanism proposed to explain it. A candidate mechanism must reproduce the observed radial field dependence, the magnitude of the response, and its timing without introducing an unmeasured process as though it were an observation.

Questions for Further Investigation

A useful follow-up experiment would vary the capacitor geometry, charging waveform, dielectric material, and measurement position while independently recording plate voltage, conduction current, and magnetic-field response.

The relevant comparisons are whether the measured magnetic response follows the rate of change of electric flux, whether departures from the ideal linear radial dependence can be explained by fringing fields and geometry, and whether any reproducible residual remains after those effects are accounted for.

Such a residual, if found, would require independent replication before being assigned to a new physical mechanism. Agreement with the Ampère–Maxwell prediction remains the baseline against which any alternative interpretation must be tested.

Conclusion

Bartlett and Corle provided a direct experimental test of the magnetic field associated with displacement current in a charging capacitor. Their reported radial dependence and approximately five-percent agreement with the predicted slope support the Ampère–Maxwell description in a region without conduction-current transport across the gap.

For PRINCIPIA HISTORICA, the value of this experiment is not that it proves a substrate. It identifies a measurable electromagnetic response and a clearly defined region in which proposed physical mechanisms can be examined against an established result.