Experiment: Millikan's Oil-Drop
What was measured, what was inferred, and what the falling drops did not reveal.
The Question
Robert A. Millikan's oil-drop experiment is remembered as a measurement of the elementary electric charge. Its historical importance is substantial. But the distinction between a measured quantity and an inferred mechanism deserves careful attention.
One specific question motivates this study: Did Millikan observe a drop moving along a stepped ballistic path, or did he observe changes in the drop's average velocity between fixed viewing marks? Those are not equivalent observations.
The Apparatus
Small oil droplets were introduced into a chamber between two approximately horizontal metal plates. A voltage applied between the plates produced a controllable vertical electric field. Illumination and a viewing telescope allowed the operator to follow individual droplets as they moved through a calibrated distance. Ionizing radiation could change a droplet's charge.
With the field off, a droplet generally descended through air. With the field applied, an electrically charged droplet could descend more slowly, remain approximately suspended, or rise, depending on the sign and magnitude of its charge and the direction of the field.
The operator did not record a continuous, high-speed position trace. The principal data were elapsed times for a drop to pass between specified crosshairs, together with field settings and other quantities needed for analysis.
The Mechanical Ledger
Choose upward as the positive direction. A simplified force accounting for a spherical drop moving slowly through air is:
Here \(q\) is the drop's charge, \(\mathcal{E}\) the signed vertical electric field, \(W_{\mathrm{eff}}\) its downward weight after buoyancy, and \(bv\) a linear approximation to viscous drag. For a spherical drop in the applicable low-speed regime, the basic drag coefficient is:
where \(\eta\) is the air viscosity and \(r\) the droplet radius. Millikan's precision analysis required a correction to this simple drag relation for very small drops; that correction matters when extracting a numerical value of charge.
Once the motion had settled to an approximately constant speed, acceleration was negligible and the balance became:
Changing the charge changes the electric force, and therefore changes the terminal velocity. This predicts distinct velocity states without requiring the drop's position to jump discontinuously.
What Was Actually Recorded?
The published experiment used transit times over known distances. If the crosshairs were separated by \(L\) and the measured transit time was \(\Delta t\), the inferred average speed was:
Millikan reported cases in which the motion of a particular droplet changed suddenly following an ionization event. Repeated measurements could yield a set of distinguishable transit times and hence distinguishable velocities. Such events supported his inference that charge was acquired or lost in discrete amounts.
But a change in transit time is not a resolved record of the trajectory during the change. A stopwatch measurement between crosshairs cannot, by itself, establish whether the transition contained a short acceleration interval, a brief mechanical impulse, an oscillation, or some other finer time structure.
Discrete Charge Is Not Discrete Position
Suppose the drop's charge changes at time \(t_0\) from \(q_1\) to \(q_2\), while the applied field remains fixed. In the simple drag model, the new terminal speed differs from the old one:
The velocity then relaxes toward its new value with a characteristic mechanical time:
For this idealized model, after a sudden charge change:
Thus even an instantaneous change in charge need not imply an instantaneous change in velocity, much less a discontinuity in position. The position remains the time integral of velocity. This is a testable mechanical model, not a claim that Millikan measured the detailed transition.
Observation, Interpretation, and Open Measurement
| Question | Experimental status |
|---|---|
| Were transit times measured between viewing marks? | Yes; this was a central measurement. |
| Did individual drops exhibit different velocity states? | Yes; abrupt changes in observed motion were reported. |
| Were the velocity changes associated with discrete charge increments? | Yes; this was Millikan's quantitative interpretation, supported by repeated charge calculations. |
| Was a staircase-shaped spatial trajectory recorded? | Not demonstrated by the published transit-time measurements. |
| Was the acceleration history at the instant of charge change resolved? | Not established by the reported timing method. |
A Modern Follow-Up Experiment
To answer the ballistic-path question directly, observe a single droplet with time-resolved position tracking while independently recording the plate voltage and the timing of an ionization event. Analyze the measured position \(z(t)\), velocity \(dz/dt\), and acceleration \(d^2z/dt^2\).
The decisive distinction is between stepped charge states, stepped velocity states, and stepped positions. Evidence for one is not automatically evidence for the others. The sampling rate and positional resolution must be sufficient to distinguish a short mechanical transient from a discontinuity or an unresolved jump.
Connection to the Proposed Energy-Balance Experiment
The historical lesson is useful for a proposed torsion or beam balance carrying supercapacitors. In Millikan's apparatus, the controlled electrical variable altered a mechanical motion; the observer then inferred charge from that response. In the proposed balance, charging one supercapacitor changes its stored energy while the mechanical response is monitored.
Three simultaneous records would be particularly informative: balance displacement \(\theta(t)\), capacitor voltage \(V(t)\), and charging current \(I(t)\). Repeating the run at different charging rates, but at the same final voltage, would help distinguish a transient response associated with current or charging power from a persistent response correlated with stored energy.
Switching the charged side provides an additional directional test. Any gravitational interpretation would still require an independent estimate of expected force and careful separation of electrical, thermal, and mechanical coupling. The energy transferred from the central battery must also be included in the apparatus's energy ledger.
Lesson: Record the motion first. Assign the mechanism second. Design the measurement so the proposed mechanisms make different, falsifiable predictions.
Historical References
R. A. Millikan, “The Isolation of an Ion, a Precision Measurement of its Charge, and the Correction of Stokes's Law,” Physical Review 32 (1911), 349–397.
R. A. Millikan, “On the Elementary Electrical Charge and the Avogadro Constant,” Physical Review 2 (1913), 109–143. Caltech archive.
R. A. Millikan, The Electron: Its Isolation and Measurement and the Determination of Some of Its Properties (1917). Read the text.