Einstein's Variable-Light-Speed Gravitational Theory
Abstract
The common summary that Einstein simply postulated a universally constant speed of light omits an important chapter of his investigations. Between 1907 and 1912 he considered gravitational effects on clocks and electromagnetic propagation. In 1912 he explicitly represented a static gravitational field by a position-dependent light-speed quantity \(c(\mathbf r)\) and proposed equations for its spatial distribution.
This audit reconstructs the principal steps, distinguishes the measurements involved, examines the conservation objection Einstein himself raised, and records what the work does—and does not—offer to an energy/substrate account of gravity. The historical equations are not presented as modern experimentally established field laws.
The Historical Postulate
In 1905 Einstein formulated the special-relativistic principle that the speed of light in vacuum is the same for inertial observers, independent of source motion. It was not derived from a mechanical model of a transmitting substrate. The ensuing theory was internally structured around that postulate.
The audit question is narrower than an attempt to disprove special relativity: must the measured propagation constant be regarded as primitive, or can a deeper physical response law explain why it has its observed value?
From the Equivalence Principle to a Variable Propagation Quantity
The 1907–1911 Investigation
By 1907 Einstein had begun asking how gravitation affects clocks and radiation. In his 1911 paper, On the Influence of Gravitation on the Propagation of Light, he treated gravitational potential as altering the coordinate description of light propagation. In first-order modernized notation, an approximate expression is:
This expression is valid only within the weak-field approximation and a chosen clock/coordinate convention. It is not a claim that a local laboratory measuring vacuum light speed with its own clock detects a changing value of \(c_0\). Einstein also used this approach to estimate gravitational deflection of starlight; that preliminary estimate was about half the value predicted by his completed 1915 theory.
The 1912 Proposal: Light Speed as a Gravitational Potential
In Lichtgeschwindigkeit und Statik des Gravitationsfeldes (1912), Einstein went further. His static field was characterized by a spatially dependent quantity \(c(\mathbf r)\). For a uniformly accelerated reference system, he obtained the illustrative linear profile:
He then proposed the source-free static equation, using \(\nabla^2\) for the spatial Laplacian:
By analogy with a gravitational potential equation, he proposed for a region containing matter:
Here \(\rho\) denotes the matter-density source in Einstein's scheme and \(\kappa\) its coupling coefficient. The notation is rendered with modern symbols; the source conventions and units are those of the historical model, not a direct substitution of SI quantities. This was a candidate field equation, not a consequence of Maxwell's equations.
From Propagation Profile to Acceleration
Einstein tried to connect the spatial profile of \(c\) to material motion. In his historical normalization, the force per unit volume on stationary matter was written in the form:
This makes the slope of the propagation quantity mechanically important. But it does not establish the separate PRINCIPIA GRAVITATIS candidate \(\mathbf g=-\tfrac12\boldsymbol\nabla v^2\). The equations use different normalizations and physical premises; identifying them would require a dimensional and dynamical derivation.
The Conservation Failure Einstein Found
Einstein did not leave the first field equation unchallenged. In a second 1912 paper, Zur Theorie des statischen Gravitationsfeldes, he noted that coupling the proposed field equation to the assumed force density could yield a nonzero net force on an isolated material distribution. A closed system should not accelerate its center of mass merely through internal gravitational interactions.
Substitution of the original source equation into the integrated force density exposes the issue:
which does not generally vanish without an additional field contribution or a revised response law. Einstein's objection was therefore not simply that the theory looked unfamiliar: the equation and its force law did not provide acceptable total force and momentum accounting.
One form of the revised nonlinear equation, in the historical normalization, is:
The additional term incorporates the field gradient itself as a contributor in the source accounting. This revision is historically significant: the gravitational field was no longer merely responding to matter density; its own field configuration mattered. This did not make the 1912 scalar theory a complete or experimentally sufficient account of gravity.
What Changed in 1913–1915?
Einstein's subsequent work with Marcel Grossmann and his later 1915 field equations moved beyond a single scalar propagation function. In general relativity, the behavior of clocks, spatial measurements, material motion, and light propagation is jointly described by spacetime geometry. The locally measured speed of vacuum light remains \(c_0\); coordinate descriptions of transit speed need not be spatially constant.
It would therefore be historically inaccurate to say that Einstein simply abandoned a viable variable-speed theory in favor of a variable-speed-of-time theory. His early treatment already involved clocks, and the later theory addressed more relationships than either one variable alone could express.
Audit of the Variable-Speed Mechanism
What the Early Equations Specify
The 1912 scheme supplies a candidate spatial field \(c(\mathbf r)\), a source term, and an attempted relationship to force. It puts propagation behavior into the gravitational description explicitly and demonstrates why conservation constraints are indispensable.
What They Do Not Specify
The field equation does not identify a microscopic electromagnetic substrate, nor does it establish a constitutive relation between electromagnetic energy density and effective permittivity or permeability. It does not distinguish guided-wave phase velocity from group velocity, or show that a coaxial shield can isolate a signal from gravitation. These are separate physical questions.
The Impedance Question
For a homogeneous, isotropic, nondispersive electromagnetic medium, the familiar relations are:
Effective \(\varepsilon\) and \(\mu\) can, mathematically, change proportionately while leaving \(Z\) unchanged and altering \(v\). But these equations do not show that a gravitational field or preexisting electromagnetic energy causes such a change. The 1912 gravitational scalar \(c(\mathbf r)\) must not silently be identified with this material-medium velocity formula.
PRINCIPIA GRAVITATIS: A Separate Candidate Chain
The present investigation asks whether existing energetic activity establishes a propagation environment which, in turn, conditions the motion of later disturbances. Its candidate sequence is:
Here \(\mathcal R\) is a deliberately undefined electromagnetic response law, not an assertion that \(\varepsilon_0\) and \(\mu_0\) have been measured to vary in vacuum. The two missing mechanistic links are (a) how ambient energy sets response, and (b) how a propagation gradient exerts acceleration on energy or matter. Einstein's 1912 work is a historical precedent for making the latter question explicit, not evidence that this particular chain is correct.
Experimental Discriminators
A useful audit must identify measurements that can distinguish mechanisms rather than merely fit known observations.
- Gas-density propagation range: compare pulse travel time or optical phase in evacuated and hydrogen-filled paths; first quantify known material refractivity and dispersion.
- Common-clock closed or nearly closed path: measure propagation delay without remote-clock synchronization while recognizing that a round trip does not independently determine each one-way speed.
- Guided versus open propagation: compare coaxial, optical-fiber, and free-space routes at controlled elevation; separate cable temperature, dielectric, mechanical strain, and electronics from any gravitational effect.
- Frequency dependence: distinguish dispersive material or plasma responses from gravitational behavior using several frequencies and polarizations.
- Conservation audit: require any new energy-to-propagation equation and acceleration law to account for force, energy transfer, momentum, and any field-energy contribution as one system.
Audit Findings
Historical finding: Einstein developed a genuine gravitational theory using position-dependent light speed in 1912. He also diagnosed a conservation problem in its simplest field equation and introduced a nonlinear correction.
Interpretive finding: variable coordinate propagation speed in Einstein's work is not evidence by itself for varying local vacuum constants or an electromagnetic substrate.
Open investigation: the possible relationships among environmental energy density, effective electromagnetic response, propagation speed, and gravitational acceleration remain separate propositions that must be physically connected and measured.
Primary Sources and Further Reading
- Einstein, A. (1911), Über den Einfluss der Schwerkraft auf die Ausbreitung des Lichtes, Annalen der Physik 35, 898–908. English translation.
- Einstein, A. (1912), Lichtgeschwindigkeit und Statik des Gravitationsfeldes, Annalen der Physik 38, 355–369. Original publication / DOI; English translation by D. H. Delphenich.
- Einstein, A. (1912), Zur Theorie des statischen Gravitationsfeldes, Annalen der Physik 38, 443–458. Original publication / DOI; Historical text, §4.
- Giulini, D., Einstein's “Prague Field Equation” of 1912. Historical and mathematical reconstruction.
- Janssen, M. and Renn, J. (2015), Arch and scaffold: How Einstein found his field equations, Physics Today. Article / DOI.